I think that sometimes we as muslims can worship our scholars as well and leave common sense behind at times.
The daleel you talk about is opinion based upon what? The prophet clearly restricted eating meat that was not killed with zabiha and so did Allah subhana wa ta'ala in the Quran.
Also lets look at the picture that the Prophet did not allow muslims to buy the meat of non muslims anywhere in hadith or Quran! Unless they had no access to islamic meat or were invited to a person of the book house. He did not make this statement without restriction he made it within a clear understanding of a certain situation!
their is a great hadeeth that says in the end of time the people who will be thought of as scholars will only be da'ees (callers to Islam). Has that time come so soon?
As for daleel you have only stated their opinion yet I have read nothing concisely written to support the claims of these scholars. A great problem amongst scholars of today who write fatwas without providing all the evidence needed to support their opinion and explanation about how they came to that conclusion. If they tell you to jump off a bridge will you do that too?
If you have some well written daleel then please pass it on! Otherwise the restriction has already been made in my eyes until I get some clear, concise islamic proof to support their claim!
I think that sometimes we as muslims can worship our scholars as well and leave common sense behind at times.
The daleel you talk about is opinion based upon what? The prophet clearly restricted eating meat that was not killed with zabiha and so did Allah subhana wa ta'ala in the Quran.
Also lets look at the picture that the Prophet did not allow muslims to buy the meat of non muslims anywhere in hadith or Quran! Unless they had no access to islamic meat or were invited to a person of the book house. He did not make this statement without restriction he made it within a clear understanding of a certain situation!
their is a great hadeeth that says in the end of time the people who will be thought of as scholars will only be da'ees (callers to Islam). Has that time come so soon?
As for daleel you have only stated their opinion yet I have read nothing concisely written to support the claims of these scholars. A great problem amongst scholars of today who write fatwas without providing all the evidence needed to support their opinion and explanation about how they came to that conclusion. If they tell you to jump off a bridge will you do that too?
If you have some well written daleel then please pass it on! Otherwise the restriction has already been made in my eyes until I get some clear, concise islamic proof to support their claim!
Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi