I think PM summed up exactly what I said to be the beliefs of the majority of christians.

And scarlett you do and have mentioned the same yourself on this very website! On the whole the basis of the trinity is the basis of christianity!

I.E. that God is 3 that makes 1.

And pm "broken" is the same thing as seperating God into 3 and then trying to explain why and how that makes 1.

You have not reiterated nothing I have not said myself.

And amen to your analysis of muslims! I agree, some are the biggest abusers of shirk in the world. Who take scholars literally as God!

As for the prophet then what he said commanded us to do and practiced is not up for us to debate unless we enter the fold of disbelief. I.E. that he was not a prophet and did not leave us upon a clear religion in which we follow his example. Should he have made any mistakes it is quite clear that according to muslim theology God corrected him at those times!

Now if you would like to talk about the authenticity of certain hadith that would be another issue entirely!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi