Your original list of parameters didn't include personal taste/features. For this only you can decide what you like to look at and how many buttons are really necessary. Toyota is still the highest resale value and most reliable.

As far as numbers go - despite recalling cars, global consumers purchased 10.23m Toyota vehicles making no 1 again. They can't all be wrong.

Go Toyota, you may not like to look at it but you will like the look of your bank account when you sell it