I agree with you and dont question your interpretation. People often put 'throwaway' comparisons in when quoteing another religion as a way of putting it down.

Comparing christianity and islam as difficult as though both only have one 'book' they are both interpreted differently - sunni / catholic / wahabi/ baptist / shia / anglican / sufi / adventist etc etc

Great minds think alike, but fools seldom differ. (English Proverb)

To the people who don't believe in free speech - stop posting ;)