I advise all the brothers here to fear Allah and stop speaking without knowledge in the religion of Allah, specifically acchabachha and the others who have made claims that they did not back with evidences and go against the authentic evidences
For example, he says: “when traveling or flying, the rules of facing the Qiblah does not apply”
It seems that you have confused the exception of a traveler praying a VOLUNTARY prayer while riding with an OBLIGATORY prayer. Please provide your evidences!
1. https://sunnah.com/bukhari:400
Also regarding standing:
The prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم was asked about the prayer on a boat: he صلى الله عليه و سلم said (roughly): pray on it standing except if you fear drowning
[ad-daraqutni: saheeh according to al-haakim and adh-dhahabi agreed]
-Shaykh al-albani رحمه الله adds a benefit on this in his book ((صفة صلاة النبي صلى الله عليه و سلم)) [description of the prophets prayer صلى الله عليه و سلم:
“And the ruling of the prayer on a plane is like the prayer on a boat, that he should pray standing if he is able, otherwise he prays sitting and makes head gestures for the bowing and prostration, as we mentioned before” (3rd edition of new print, page 69 [arabic version])
I am not saying that it is not allowed to pray sitting on a plane, Allah knows best, you can review what the scholars said about that (like above). What I am saying is dont give rulings based on your thoughts and opinions. I would like to see your evidence that facing the qiblah is dropped when traveling
Asalamu alaykom wa rahmato Allahi wa barakatuh
I advise all the brothers here to fear Allah and stop speaking without knowledge in the religion of Allah, specifically acchabachha and the others who have made claims that they did not back with evidences and go against the authentic evidences
For example, he says: “when traveling or flying, the rules of facing the Qiblah does not apply”
It seems that you have confused the exception of a traveler praying a VOLUNTARY prayer while riding with an OBLIGATORY prayer. Please provide your evidences!
1. https://sunnah.com/bukhari:400
Also regarding standing:
The prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم was asked about the prayer on a boat: he صلى الله عليه و سلم said (roughly): pray on it standing except if you fear drowning
[ad-daraqutni: saheeh according to al-haakim and adh-dhahabi agreed]
-Shaykh al-albani رحمه الله adds a benefit on this in his book ((صفة صلاة النبي صلى الله عليه و سلم)) [description of the prophets prayer صلى الله عليه و سلم:
“And the ruling of the prayer on a plane is like the prayer on a boat, that he should pray standing if he is able, otherwise he prays sitting and makes head gestures for the bowing and prostration, as we mentioned before” (3rd edition of new print, page 69 [arabic version])
I am not saying that it is not allowed to pray sitting on a plane, Allah knows best, you can review what the scholars said about that (like above). What I am saying is dont give rulings based on your thoughts and opinions. I would like to see your evidence that facing the qiblah is dropped when traveling
May Allah guide us to the truth